| Member | Score |
| Kodiak | .300 |
| Rail City Slinger | .304 |
| Marshal Cooper | .289 |
| Rodeo Romeo | .304 |
| South Fork Slim | .292 |
| Master Gunfighter | .287 |
| Kid Creggar | .284 |
| Spinner | .306 |
| Tank | .304 |
| High Plains Drifter | .319 |
| The Gunslinger | .317 |
| Colt McCoy | .312 |
| Hell On Wheels | .289 |
| Shaniko | .335 |
| Ol Gun | .311 |
| The Virginian | .340 |
| Tin Bender | .330 |
| Caleb | .324 |
| Bad Burro | .286 |
| Parttime | .296 |
| Kopperhead Kid | .294 |
| Kid Curry | .308 |
| Muletrain | .333 |
| Thirsty | .333 |
| K.K. Kid | .342 |
| Doc Holli Day | .357 |
| J.R. | .316 |